|Book(s)|| A Storm of Swords (appears)|
A Feast for Crows (appendix)
A Dance with Dragons (appendix)
A Storm of Swords
Black Bernarr is part of the great ranging by the Night's Watch and survives the fight at the Fist. He breaks his ankle in a deep hole on the march south from the Fist, however, and is then carried on a horse. He is skeptical of Samwell Tarly having slain an Other with a dragonglass dagger.