Difference between revisions of "Sailor's Wife/Theories"

From A Wiki of Ice and Fire
Jump to: navigation, search
m (Gerion Lannister)
m (References and Notes)
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The [[Sailor's Wife]] theory is that her real husband was a  [[House Lannister|Lannister]].
+
{{Theory_Policy}}
The basis of this is that her daughter is named [[Lanna (Happy Port)|Lanna]] <ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 34|Chapter 34]], Cat of the Canals</ref>which is the feminine form the name Lann from which the family got its mame <ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 7|Chapter 7]  Cerei</ref><ref>[[A Game of Thrones}, [[A Game of Thrones-Appendix|Appendix]]</ref> and is used to connect females to House Lannister. Her daughter has golden hair a trait of the Lannister's.<ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 34|Chapter 34]], Cat of the Canals</ref>
 
  
Her husband is thought to be ether [[Tyrion Lannister]] or [[Gerion Lannister]].
+
One theory about the [[Sailor's Wife]] is that her real husband was a [[House Lannister|Lannister]].
  
==Tyrion Lannister==
+
==Theory==
If this was true she would be his first wife [[Tysha]]. The information supporting that  is that Lanna is the right age to be a daughter of that marriage and acording to her statment that she was the same age as Lanna when she gave birth she would be the right age to be Tysha. <ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 34|Chapter 34]], Cat of the Canals</ref> Her working in a whorehouse support the the statement [[Tywin Lannister]] made before he died she was "Wherever whore go." <ref>[[A Storm of Swords]], [[A Storm of Swords-Chapter 77]] Tyrion</ref>
+
The basis of this idea is that her daughter is named [[Lanna (Happy Port)|Lanna]]<ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 34|Chapter 34]], Cat of the Canals</ref> which is the feminine form of the name [[Lann the Clever|Lann]], from which the family name is derived.<ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 7|Chapter 7]], Cersei</ref><ref>[[A Game of Thrones]], [[A Game of Thrones-Appendix|Appendix]]</ref> Her daughter has golden hair, a [[House Lannister|
 +
Lannister]] trait.<ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 34|Chapter 34]], Cat of the Canals</ref>
  
difficulty with this is that Tyrion was not a sailor  and why she is in [[Braavos]] and is not dead as [[Yna]] predicts..
+
==Possible Husbands==
 +
Her husband is thought to be either [[Tyrion Lannister|Tyrion]] or [[Gerion Lannister]].
  
==Gerion Lannister==
+
===Tyrion Lannister===
 +
She could be his first wife, [[Tysha]].  [[Lanna (Happy Port)|Lanna]] is the right age to be a daughter of their marriage. The [[Sailor's Wife]] also states that she was the same age as Lanna is now when she gave birth to her. This puts her at about the same age when she gave birth as Tysha when she was married to Tyrion.<ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 34|Chapter 34]], Cat of the Canals</ref> The fact that she works in a whorehouse supports the statement [[Tywin Lannister]] made before he died when he said she was "wherever whores go."<ref>[[A Storm of Swords]], [[A Storm of Swords-Chapter 77|Chapter 77]], Tyrion</ref>
  
He could be the husband because he was a sailor and is dead.<ref>[[A Game of Thrones}, [[A Game of Thrones-Appendix|Appendix]]</ref> He has been to Braavos.
+
=====Counter Arguments=====
 +
* Tyrion was not a sailor.
 +
* How and why did she go to [[Braavos]]?
 +
* Tyrion is not dead as [[Yna]] predicts.<ref>[[A Feast for Crows]], [[A Feast for Crows-Chapter 34|Chapter 34]], Cat of the Canals</ref>
 +
* Tysha was not a whore.
  
==References and Notes==
+
===Gerion Lannister===
{{references|3}}  
+
He could be the Lannister husband because he was a sailor and is thought to be dead.<ref>[[A Game of Thrones]], [[A Game of Thrones-Appendix|Appendix]]</ref> He has been to Braavos.
 +
 
 +
=====Counter Arguments=====
 +
* Lanna is fourteen, whereas Joy Hill, Gerion's bastard daughter by an unknown woman, is eleven
 +
 
 +
==References==
 +
{{references}}  
 
[[Category:Theories]]
 
[[Category:Theories]]

Latest revision as of 21:26, 2 March 2018

 Theories may be removed if ... 
  1. Stated as questions or possibilities.
  2. More appropriate for another article.
  3. Illogical or previously disproven.
  4. Proven by canon source, and moved to main page.
  5. Speculative and lacking any evidence to support arguments.
  6. Responding to another theory (use discussion page instead).
  • This does not include responses that are also standalone theories.
  • Usage of an indented bullet does not imply the statement is a response.

One theory about the Sailor's Wife is that her real husband was a Lannister.

Theory

The basis of this idea is that her daughter is named Lanna[1] which is the feminine form of the name Lann, from which the family name is derived.[2][3] Her daughter has golden hair, a Lannister trait.[4]

Possible Husbands

Her husband is thought to be either Tyrion or Gerion Lannister.

Tyrion Lannister

She could be his first wife, Tysha. Lanna is the right age to be a daughter of their marriage. The Sailor's Wife also states that she was the same age as Lanna is now when she gave birth to her. This puts her at about the same age when she gave birth as Tysha when she was married to Tyrion.[5] The fact that she works in a whorehouse supports the statement Tywin Lannister made before he died when he said she was "wherever whores go."[6]

Counter Arguments
  • Tyrion was not a sailor.
  • How and why did she go to Braavos?
  • Tyrion is not dead as Yna predicts.[7]
  • Tysha was not a whore.

Gerion Lannister

He could be the Lannister husband because he was a sailor and is thought to be dead.[8] He has been to Braavos.

Counter Arguments
  • Lanna is fourteen, whereas Joy Hill, Gerion's bastard daughter by an unknown woman, is eleven

References