Difference between revisions of "Talk: House Chyttering"

From A Wiki of Ice and Fire
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 4: Line 4:
 
That said, I haven't edited the article yet. Just thought I'd stir up discussion first. [[User:Benethon Stark|Benethon Stark]] 16:13, 19 January 2012 (UTC)
 
That said, I haven't edited the article yet. Just thought I'd stir up discussion first. [[User:Benethon Stark|Benethon Stark]] 16:13, 19 January 2012 (UTC)
 
::Well there is certainly conflicting information. I looked on [http://www.lagardedenuit.com/wiki/index.php?title=Maison_Chyttering the French site] and they noted this as well. Apparently besides Dragonstone and Storm's End the house could also be sworn to King's Landing. I think the best thing to do is note it and ask Ran. With Linda he is writing a book with GRRM so maybe he could check with GRRM.[[User:Scafloc|Scafloc]] 22:47, 19 January 2012 (UTC)
 
::Well there is certainly conflicting information. I looked on [http://www.lagardedenuit.com/wiki/index.php?title=Maison_Chyttering the French site] and they noted this as well. Apparently besides Dragonstone and Storm's End the house could also be sworn to King's Landing. I think the best thing to do is note it and ask Ran. With Linda he is writing a book with GRRM so maybe he could check with GRRM.[[User:Scafloc|Scafloc]] 22:47, 19 January 2012 (UTC)
 +
:It appears that there is no basis for the claim of it being sworn to Storms End. They are listed as followers of Stannis in the Appendix of A Feast for Crows. Apparently the hairy bear read this as they were from the Stormlands since they are listed near supporters from the Stormlands. There is no list of houses from the Stormlands in A Feast for Crows' Appendix. The heraldry site on Westeros and the web site Hand of The King list them as as from the Crownlands which includes houses sworn to Dragonstone. It is undisputed that their overlord is now Baratheon of Dragonstone and it is most likely that they are sworn to Dagraonstone.
 +
[[User:ASHaber|Ser Ash the Red]] 21:06, 20 January 2012 (UTC)

Revision as of 21:06, 20 January 2012

House Chyttering being sworn to Storm's End may have just been a typo. Besides the semi-canon sources before, Lord Chyttering is mentioned by Davos in A Storm of Swords as apparently being resident (or sworn) to Dragonstone, which is evident as the local Dragonstone guards know him. Combine with that the fact that all the Storm Lords were with Renly before Blackwater, so locals guards (who probably don't care much about lords of this or that) aren't going to know a Stormlord they've never seen.

That said, I haven't edited the article yet. Just thought I'd stir up discussion first. Benethon Stark 16:13, 19 January 2012 (UTC)

Well there is certainly conflicting information. I looked on the French site and they noted this as well. Apparently besides Dragonstone and Storm's End the house could also be sworn to King's Landing. I think the best thing to do is note it and ask Ran. With Linda he is writing a book with GRRM so maybe he could check with GRRM.Scafloc 22:47, 19 January 2012 (UTC)
It appears that there is no basis for the claim of it being sworn to Storms End. They are listed as followers of Stannis in the Appendix of A Feast for Crows. Apparently the hairy bear read this as they were from the Stormlands since they are listed near supporters from the Stormlands. There is no list of houses from the Stormlands in A Feast for Crows' Appendix. The heraldry site on Westeros and the web site Hand of The King list them as as from the Crownlands which includes houses sworn to Dragonstone. It is undisputed that their overlord is now Baratheon of Dragonstone and it is most likely that they are sworn to Dagraonstone.

Ser Ash the Red 21:06, 20 January 2012 (UTC)