From A Wiki of Ice and Fire
|Book(s)|| A Game of Thrones (Appears)|
A Storm of Swords (Appears)
A Dance with Dragons (Appears)
A Game of Thrones
A Storm of Swords
The brothers of the Night's Watch left to defend the Wall from the assault by the wildlings named one of the straw dummies after him. During the choosing of the new Lord Commander of the Night's Watch, Othell put his name forth. In the end he withdrew his name from the election, though he also refused to support Janos Slynt's candidacy.
A Dance with Dragons
Othell Yarwyck is greatly angered by many of the decisions Jon Snow is making as Lord Commander.